Display options
Cite
Barthélémy JM. Importance et extension de l'approche qualitative dans la méthode phénoméno-structurale en psychopathologie. [Importance and extension of the qualitative approach in phenomeno-structural method in psychopathology]. Bull Soc Sci Med Grand Duche Luxemb. 2006;(2):249-64
Barthélémy, J. M. (2006). Importance et extension de l'approche qualitative dans la méthode phénoméno-structurale en psychopathologie. [Importance and extension of the qualitative approach in phenomeno-structural method in psychopathology]. Bulletin de la Societe des sciences medicales du Grand-Duche de Luxembourg, (2), 249-64.
Barthélémy, J M. "Importance et extension de l'approche qualitative dans la méthode phénoméno-structurale en psychopathologie." [Importance and extension of the qualitative approach in phenomeno-structural method in psychopathology]. Bulletin de la Societe des sciences medicales du Grand-Duche de Luxembourg vol. ,2 (2006): 249-64.
Barthélémy JM. Importance et extension de l'approche qualitative dans la méthode phénoméno-structurale en psychopathologie. [Importance and extension of the qualitative approach in phenomeno-structural method in psychopathology]. Bull Soc Sci Med Grand Duche Luxemb. 2006;(2):249-64. French. PMID: 17124801.
Copy Download .nbib Format: NLM
Share it on

Bull Soc Sci Med Grand Duche Luxemb. 2006;(2):249-64.

[Importance and extension of the qualitative approach in phenomeno-structural method in psychopathology].

Bulletin de la Societe des sciences medicales du Grand-Duche de Luxembourg

[Article in French]
J M Barthélémy

Affiliations

  1. Université de Savoie. [email protected]

PMID: 17124801

Abstract

Fundamental principles of phenomeno-structural method partly originate from a phenomenological approach in psychiatry for which, as Jaspers says, "the important thing is less the study of innumerable cases than the intuitive and major comprehension of some particular ones". It means that, far from traditional statistical proceedings, it does not give any priority to the temptation of a cumulative and accumulative collection of data, for which it even receives their greatest misgivings, leaving it out of its procedures. This method also owes a lot to Bergson's insistence on the qualitative characteristics of the "immediate data of consciousness" and of experienced temporality, for which analytical and chronological fragmentations can do nothing but distort the authentically comprehensive grasping, and make them loose their specificity, unity and thus the indecomposability that, by nature, they precisely contain. According to Eugene Minkowski, the psychopathical break-up, proceeding from the deep heart of life, is essentially going to express itself, with its own properties, as a qualitative modification. In this way, the study of some cases carefully chosen, in accordance with their "typical" value, is more important than a blind acquisition of data, i.e. without previous option, orientation or perspective. Starting from their spontaneous words collected during a conversation, the meticulous analysis of the language of the patients, put in resonance with the vivid metaphors of the language in which they are expressed, as Minkowski will so brilliantly show, or via mediations connecting image and language, as in the experiment of the Rorschach--particularly approached in its essential mechanisms by his wife Francoise Minkowska--represents, from this point of view, a mediator and an irreplaceable instrument of a qualitative approach of a normal as well as a pathological personality and, more widely, of the person itself.

MeSH terms

Publication Types